More Bad Financial Advice

By Stacey Bradford | Aug 18, 2009 |

Unfortunately, there’s a lot of bad advice out there. Last week I posted a blog entry about a questionable recommendation I came across involving credit cards and home equity lines of credit.  Then today, I read some awful counsel regarding debt repayment that I hope you’ll steer clear of.

An Illinois based financial services firm believes consumers should delay paying off their debt so they can instead save money for the long term. I’ve now read this press release multiple times and I just can’t believe the company let this document get out the door. I agree that we should all prepare for the future. But at what cost? It’s simply too expensive (and foolish) to carry unnecessary obligations, especially when interest rates on credit cards often top 20%.

Before the stock market and real estate boom crashed, many people convinced themselves (with a little help from some in the financial industry) that borrowing money was as American as apple pie. While I think that carrying some debt is okay — including a fixed rate mortgage — many consumer loans are outrageously priced and should get paid off as soon as possible.

Having said that, I do believe it’s important to have at least six months worth of savings set aside for an emergency. I also think you should aggressively save for retirement. But before you can work toward either of these goals, you had better stop throwing money away on high interest debt. The only way you could possibly justify paying the rates on a credit card or some other consumer loan is if you are making more on your money in the market. And that’s certainly not the case these days.

What if you do lose your job? For one thing, your overall expenses will be lower if you’re not saddled with consumer debt. Plus, if you maintain good credit and your situation gets desperate, you can always put some of your expenses on your Visa or AmEx. Then just make sure to pay off the balance as soon as you’re employed again so you can limit the overall interest paid.

I wonder what bad advice I’ll come across next week.

Money, Money, Money image by borman818, CC 2.0.

 
Reply to Story

MoneyWatch TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    AceNewsService

    08/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    This is a great article Stacey and very well written and l
    totally agree with your comments about paying off credit
    cards and loans when they are above 20% like Barclaycard
    and Littlewoods Personal Finance and l have heard of some
    even higher. My advice as a person with 20 years experience
    in financial management services is to only borrow what you
    need and repay as soon as possible. The area that was useful
    was balance transfers for 6 months with nothing to pay, until
    the global financial crisis. Now it is interest on even them
    with banks like Lloyds Bank as l learned when l phoned for a
    client the other day.

    This person had been using balance transfers for years to
    fund business capital and repaying but of course banks made
    no money, so they decide to charge interest. But not making
    it clear to the clients just changing their terms and conditions
    with a letter so onerous you need a law degree to decipher.

    Anyway he was in a mess and was unaware of new interest
    regulations as l am sure a number of other people have fallen
    foul.

    Keep up the good work Moneywatch and l will keep on adding
    your news to my network.

    Ian K Draper

  •  
    2

    rockymtnrick

    08/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    Stacey:
    The all or nothing response doesn't work for me, either. While I agree saving for six month's expenses and long-term over paying off debt doesn't make sense, neither does paying off debt while having zero savings.

    I'm betting the people in these situations have no savings, leading to additional CC debt when minor emergencies happen.

    Given that, what would be your advice? One month's worth of cash before debt? Splitting between saving and paying until some minimum saving is reached? Is there a statistical minimum savings amount that would smooth out the bumps?

  •  
    3

    gmoeller1

    08/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    During the years leading to the current financial crisis I was repeatedly outraged by columnist "experts" who chided folks wanting to pay down debt with windfall money. "Why would you do a stupid thing like that?" they'd sneer. "If your interest rate is lower than the average stock market yield you are losing money."

    In all their learned pontificating, not a word about risk differential. No hint that there's a difference between 100% certain early debt retirement savings that can be calculated to the penny vs. whatever a given investment product happens to do from day to day or year to year, with no guarantee that anything other than an index fund will actually track market performance, even in good years.

    Which is more desireable, savings from retiring a 5% mortgage and the resulting freedom from future monthly payments, or hypothetical wealth from an investment product that may set you up for life - or collapse leaving you without even your buy-in capital? There's no right answer; it's a decision each of us must make based on our goals, values, and situational context.

    Anyone who presumes to advise you on investments without mentioning differential risk is probably a shill for a product, vendor, or industry. Beware!

  •  
    4

    felicia luo

    08/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    Stacey,you`re gorgeous!
    i like this article, you know i just graduated from college but it seems that the whole world keep on talking about financial issues, my parents ,friends all tell me to manage my money properly `cause i am a totally shopaholic. i have no choice but to read lots of recommendations which turns out to be useless,after reading your article,i think it`s time to follow your advise and do the decision myself.Thanks.

  •  
    5

    perkinsonpm

    08/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    I too believe in both saving and paying off debt. This past stock market down took our retirement out the window, still have the savings, but don't trust the stock market any longer. Wish we would have taken the money out of the market sooner and paid off debt, we would be better off now. Thanks

  •  
    6

    mpollak@...

    08/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    I left post yesterday and it has shown on this list, now it is no more there?
    Why?

  •  
    7

    conlad

    08/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    High time people learnt debt is never good. The less debt you have, the freer and happier you can be. Never bet your future on variable rates, for they can crush your hopes and dreams of years to come in a single day (stock crashes, devaluations, crisis, etc).

    For your debt, go for fixed rates always. For your investments, go only with things you clearly know and trust and follow on regularly. Do this and you will be rather fine.

  •  
    8

    rnotaro@...

    08/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    Stacey

    While I agree that you should always pay off high interest debt (credit cards) I think you're forgetting one key component when factoring whether to save or pay down debt or save: inflation.

    With the trillion dollar 'stimulus' package being financed by printing money, inflation will soon be rearing its ugly head. I have delayed paying off the loans I took out for my childrens' college education as long as I could. I think within 5 years I will be paying them off 50 cents on the dollar.

    Another factor concerning college loans. With such a troubled job market isn't it possible that the federal government - in their neverending quest to win votes - will pass legislation to forgive federally backed college loans?

  •  
    9

    Wise-Money

    08/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: More Bad Financial Advice

    Good advice may be difficult to manage but Stacey is absolutely right. The time-old adage of, "never a lender and borrow be," has echoed true through the ages.

    I'm opposed to people thinking that it is okay for the government to pick up the tab for their spending. Forgiveness comes with a price to everyone - especially those of us who pay our debts.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement

Stacey Bradford

Stacey L. Bradford covers personal finance with a focus on issues that affect families. Her first book, The Wall Street Journal. Financial Guidebook for New Parents, hits shelves June 2009. She was previously an associate editor at SmartMoney.com for more than 10 years.

Stacey Bradford

Jolie Solomon

Jolie Solomon is sitting in for Stacey Bradford, who is on maternity leave. She has been a reporter, writer, or editor at many publications, including The Wall Street Journal, Newsweek, Fortune Small Business, More and the the late lamented Cincinnati Post.

Jolie Solomon

Click Here
track your portfolio