Kathy Kristof

Devil in the Details

College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

By Kathy Kristof | Aug 24, 2009 |

College students appear to be frighteningly ignorant about one of the biggest risks they’re likely to face in higher education: Toxic debt.

An analysis released today found that nearly two-thirds of the undergraduate students who borrowed for school took out something called “private” student loans before they had exhausted their borrowing power with federally-guaranteed student loans. That’s the equivalent of saying “I could have borrowed money from Mom, but I decided to go to a loan shark instead.”

Think I’m exaggerating? Here’s the deal. Federal student loans currently are issued at a 6.8% fixed rateĀ or less, depending on whether you have financial need. If you get a so-called “subsidized” federal student loan, your rate will be lower and the government will pay the interest while you’re in school. That vastly cuts your cost of credit. Like Mom, the federal government also is sympathetic to your ability to repay, offering something called “income-based” repayment that almost guarantees that you won’t have to pay more than you can afford when you get out of school.

If you get a private loan, the upfront fees can reach 10% and your interest rate is likely to be in the double-digits and adjustable, changing as frequently as once a month. Generally speaking, there’s no “cap” on these loans, meaning that there’s no limit on how high the cost of your credit could soar if interest rates rise. The highest rates are charged to those who can least afford the debt, said Lauren Asher, president of The Institute for College Access & Success. TICAS’s affiliate, the Project on Student Debt, conducted the analysis.

Using private loans is a lot like using credit cards to finance college, Asher added. But there’s one compelling difference. You can discharge credit card debt in bankruptcy. Student loan debt can haunt you for the rest of your life.

Private loans historically have been issued with far fewer interest disclosures than other types of debt, including mortgages and credit cards. A law passed last year will increase disclosure as of next February, but final rules issued by the Federal Reserve Board fall short of fully protecting the unsophisticated borrowers who take out student debt, according to TICAS. TheirĀ analysis of the Fed rules spell out a variety of areas where they believe students are still at risk.

The moral of this story: Study up on student debt, or risk the toughest lesson of your life–being haunted by toxic debt forever.

 
Reply to Story

MoneyWatch TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    cammcharg

    08/24/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    She's absolutely right about student loan debt being toxic and lenders being loan sharks. I come from a working class family, and my mother and grandmother co-sgned for me to get an education and to have a better, more productive life. I now have over six figure debt with monthly payments over $2000, and little hope of ever having a normal life with a family and a home. In addition, my mother and grandmother may lose everything. Private student loans are strangely the only form of debt not covered by consumer bankruptcy protection. This is a crime, and something must be done to reverse that. Please contact your congress people and senators, and look up www.studentloanjustice.org to take action about our nation's current student loan debt crisis.

  •  
    2

    Kathy Kristof

    08/26/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    I wish your story was less common. I wrote a long
    investigative story about private loans about a year ago and
    ran into dozens of graduates who were being eaten alive by
    debt. In most cases, the culprit was private loans that
    charged interest rates of up to 20% and could only be
    "deferred" if the student was willing to pay a fee. In most
    cases, the students didn't know that they were getting a
    private loan when they signed up because the differences
    were kept subtle, the disclosures delayed, until it was too
    late. Students, meanwhile, have been lured into a false sense
    of security, thinking that "student loans" are all the safe,
    federally-guaranteed type. As so many are learning the hard
    way, they're not.

  •  
    3

    leedits

    08/27/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    The credit crunch for college students is going to haunt us all. Lets band together to create a loud voice. Isn't this as big of an issue as health care these days?

  •  
    4

    Synitta

    08/27/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    "private" student loans ARE DEFINITELY toxic but sometimes
    if you want to go to school, you have no choice...like myself.
    The government wouldn't even give me ALL of the money to
    cover ALL the tuition of my schooling so I had no choice but
    to borrow from someone who WOULD give me the
    money...the toxic lender. Being able to afford to go to school
    is MUCH easier said than done and I REALLY wish getting
    government funds was as simple as the article above makes it
    seem...

    The icing on the cake of me borrowing money so I could get
    an education...I finished school and upon my graduation date,
    got laid off my job so now, it's one more bill I can't pay even
    though I can say "hey, I've got a degree!"

  •  
    5

    valeriehg

    08/27/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    A college education should be available to everyone who wants it and it shouldn't cost anything! Our educational system, like our health care system is a sham.

  •  
    6

    conlad

    08/27/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    Sorry about that Synitta. I hope things pick up for you.

    And you bring up a point I'm also interested in. Federal funds, anywhere in the world mind you, are quite hard to get and hardly advertised. Would you mind writing an article with tips and guidance on how to access these funds Kathy? That for sure will help everyone more than just saying private loans are toxic (all private loans, for anything, are toxic in one way or another, though these ones border on the criminal side).

  •  
    7

    Kathy Kristof

    08/27/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    It's obviously too late for Synitta, but the federal government
    changed financial aid rules to boost allowable loan limits for
    students. If that's not enough, parents can now borrow up to
    the full cost of college. The parent loans are somewhat
    higher rate than the student loans, but they're still better
    than the toxic debts.
    The main point here is to check your other options first. Call
    1-800-4-FED-AID or check out the fabulous student aid web
    site www.finaid.org. Also be sure to fill out the FAFSA--even
    if you don't think you'll qualify for other aid. It's required to
    get government student loans.
    And, yes, I'll revisit this issue with a how-to soon. I promise.

  •  
    8

    Synitta

    08/28/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    Kathy K., I received the "financial aid" I had through the
    FAFSA. I think A LOT of people think that's "free" money but I
    STILL have to pay back EVERY CENT they gave me to attend
    class...it's just at a different interest rate than the "private"
    loan I have.

    I'll be waiting to read your "how-to" article!!! happy

  •  
    9

    ChiliGuy

    08/31/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    My son just filled out the FAFSA app and the results indicate he doesn't qualify for Pell grants, and he can't borrow from the gov't. without a $7,100 "family contribution" towards his school bills. Neither his mom nor I can afford that (we're divorced)... so is he just out of luck or is his only alternative to take out one of these toxic loans for $7,100? Or do I have to take out one of these parent loans?

    He's 21 and hasn't lived with either one of us for almost a year. It is a shame, really, that these things can't be simpler and easier.

  •  
    10

    Kathy Kristof

    08/31/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    Did he file as an "independent" student? He should have, which
    would give him more aid eligibility. If not, tell him to go at it
    again. And you might want to invest in a book called "Paying for
    College Without Going Broke," by Kalman Chany. It's a great
    step-by-step guide to filling out the FAFSA, which is trickier
    than it looks (and it looks pretty bad).

  •  
    11

    Kathy Kristof

    09/06/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    From Alan via email:

    "I've been thinking over this private vs. federal loan question
    alot, and while I see astonishingly harmful private loans being
    doled out , federal loans are clearly far worse in terms of
    consumer protections. Both have no meaningful BK
    protections, but at least privates have truth in lending,
    FDCPA, dtatutes of limitations, and other protections (federal
    loans don't).

    Default penalties, and collection powers for federal loans are
    also far, far stronger than those allowed for private loans (or
    any other type of loan in this country, for that matter.

    There is alot more to add here...check out the
    http://www.facebook.com/l/;studentloanjustice.org site, or
    just email me to continue the conversation.

    BTW: The default rate for federal loans is about 1 in 3
    borrowers, I estimate...don't believe the DOE."

  •  
    12

    Kathy Kristof

    09/06/09 | Report as spam

    RE: College Finance 101: Beware of Toxic Debt

    Alan, I realize that the federal government has tremendous
    collection powers with federal loans, but I think that's
    appropriate given the low rates they provide and the fact
    that they're playing with taxpayer dollars.

    With private loans, you have no interest rate protections. A
    company is simply making a business decision about whether
    you'll be credit worthy. I don't understand why government
    would give these companies, which are often issuing the
    equivalent of subprime loans, bankruptcy preferences that
    can turn their borrowers into indentured servants forever.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement

Kathy Kristof

Kathy Kristof is a syndicated personal finance columnist, speaker and author of three books, including the recently updated Investing 101 (Bloomberg, 2008).

Kathy Kristof

Click Here
track your portfolio