Loopholes for Breaking Your Lease

By Alison Rogers | Jul 15, 2009 |

Dear Ali;

My hours at my job have been cut back significantly — I’m not unemployed but it’s a struggle to make ends meet. I’ve heard that you can’t break your lease if you lose your job, but are there any loopholes I could take advantage of? I really need to move to a cheaper place.

A: Every lease is an individual contract, so really every one is different. But there are usually only four possible soft spots in a lease:

  1. Military Duty. Members of the armed services often know that they’ll get called up at a moment’s notice, so sometimes it’s written in beforehand that you can break your lease with a month or two notice if you are called. Some states have protections also; for instance, the Maryland People’s Law Library notes that there are lease break protections in Maryland.
  2. Domestic Violence. Some municipalities provide that you can break a lease if you have to move out of a violent domestic situation. But the laws can be very specific: filing a police report, for instance, is merely a claim of domestic violence, not proof. You’ll usually need a court order of protection as proof. Our friends at the University of Illinois Tenant Union point out that, in Illinois, you also have to send written notice to your landlord three days before you move out.
  3. Covenant of “Quiet Enjoyment.” This may be stated in slightly different ways in different states, but generally, when you sign a lease, you’re supposed to get quiet use of the leased premises. “In Texas, it’s implied in every lease, whether it’s in the lease or not,” notes Aimee Hess, author of the Texas Attorney Blog, and the president of Law Offices of Aimee Hess, P.C., located in Streetman, Tex. “Say your neighbor’s son is forming a punk-rock band in an apartment with thin walls, and they practice every night from 8-2. That’s a violation of the covenant of quiet enjoyment.”
    However, note that you can’t just move out. You need to notify your landlord (and “notify” always means “in writing”) and give him the chance to correct the problem.
  4. Implied Warranty of Habitability. “Habitability” means about what you think it means — an apartment with a gaping hole in the roof, or one that is overrun with mice, is not habitable. Just like with the covenant of quiet enjoyment, though, you have to notify the landlord, and you run the risk that he’ll correct the defect. That closes the loophole, and while it makes your apartment better, it means you can’t break your lease.

Read More:

 
Reply to Story

MoneyWatch TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    techr412

    07/21/09 | Report as spam

    Can I break my lease?

    My husband and I leased a house for a year beginning on January 18, 2009. We began to experience difficulty with the owner/landlord in repairing or fulfilling obligations that we requested. For instance, there was a large pile of debris outside of our kitchen door that consisted of broken glass, nails, wood, etc. The house had been newly remodeled. We asked the owner repeatedly to clean it up. He never complied. My husband finally did it due to safety issues. Oven never worked properly. A few attempts to fix it occured. Remote controllers to the ceiling fans were never given to us after asking repeatedly. As a result we did not have use of the fans. Screens on windows were missing or torn. Owner told repeatedly. This was disregarded. Cockroaches were in the cupboards, oven, under the sink. Asked him to spray. He said he did not cover that expense. A/C was broken. Requested that it be fixed. After going through a heatwave and repeatedly asking, a reapirman was sent out. This took 2 weeks. Owner did like the price. Took another week to get it fixed. We finally had enough. Wrote a formal letter stating all of this and that because of his lack of concern and violating Health and Safety Codes along with Civil Codes, he had broken the lease. We vacated the premises, cleaned it and turned in the key. We had the walk through and signed it. It stated that the lease had terminated. He did not give us a copy. Said he would mail it along with the rest of the deposit that was due us. We did not get the deposit or the copy of the walk through. Instead he sent us a letter stating the charges that he was with holding due to damages to the house that he had not written down during the walk through or discussed with us and that we were still liable for rent until the house rented. Some of the charges were for things that we had told him were not our rersponsibility like missing toilet paper holders which we never had, a broken hinge on a bathroom vanity, damage to a kitchen window. We never opened the kitchen window because the blinds did not work properly. They would not raise up. He would not fix them. So on and so on. We responded to his letter by saying that we would not pay for these damages and that all rental obligations were stopped because the lease was broken by him. We asked that the deposit be paid and that a copy of the final walk through be sent to us as agreed. We also told him that if he chose to pursue the matter we would file a claim in court along with the Better Business Bureau and Board of Realtors. We researched renters rights and what is expected of a landlord/owner. We feel he has clearly broken the lease and that it is terminated. Are we in the right?

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here

Alison Rogers

Since graduating from Harvard summa cum laude, Alison Rogers has been a reporter, an editor, a real-estate agent, a Wall Street desk jockey, a columnist, a failed flipper, and a landlady. A member of the National Association of Realtors, she currently sells and rents luxury co-ops in Manhattan for the Chelsea-based firm DG Neary. (If you've got $27,500 a month, the firm has an apartment for you!) Her book, Diary of a Real Estate Rookie, was called "a valuable guide for rookie buyers" by AOL/Walletpop, "beach-read fun" by the New York Observer, and "witty" by Newsweek.

Alison Rogers

Click Here
track your portfolio