Don’t Go Overboard With Inflation Protection

By Charlie Farrell | Sep 21, 2009 |

The most common question I get these days from retirees is “how do I protect myself from high inflation?” While inflation protection is important, if you only focus on inflation, you may be losing out on opportunities to produce more income today.

Low Rates. Many retirees are sitting on the sidelines in cash afraid to invest their money because they don’t want to get whipsawed by inflation down the road. While this is a big concern, by sitting in cash, you’re forfeiting the chance to prudently earn more income in today’s markets.

  • If you’re in cash, you’re probably making somewhere around 0.25 percent on your money.
  • But if over the last year you’d been invested, for example, in a bond portfolio that was designed to track the Barclay’s U.S. Aggregate Bond Index, you’d have received a little more than 4 percent interest on your money.  This index is a mix of intermediate term Treasury, U.S. agency and high-quality corporate bonds.
  • While 4 percent isn’t great, it’s 16 times more than what you may have been earning in cash.
  • Let’s assume you sit in cash for two years waiting for inflation, and the interest rate environment doesn’t change. Well, you’ve earned about 0.50 percent from your cash over two years when you probably could have earned about 8 percent if you were more fully invested. So that’s a real opportunity cost.

Distributions. Now, let’s assume you need to take distributions from your accounts because you’re retired. If you want to take 4 percent this year, and are only earning 0.25 percent, this means you’re eating up 3.75 percent of your principal. If this continued for two years, you’d eat up 7.5 percent of your savings.

  • But if you were more fully invested and earned more interest, you could distribute the income payments, which would lessen the need to touch the principal.
  • If you’re retired, you need to balance the risks of generating current income to feed distributions versus the threat of inflation down the road.

TIPS. You may be familiar with Treasury Inflation Protected Securities (TIPS), and they’re a very good long term inflation hedge. But the problem with TIPS today is they don’t produce much income for you to live on. So if you load up on TIPS and we don’t get high inflation, or it takes years for inflation to emerge, you may be forced to spend more of your principal to pay the bills.

Flexibility. As long as you keep your fixed income holdings flexible, you should be able to respond to inflation by eventually buying bonds that provide higher income, while still earning more income today.

  • One of the best methods is to simply ladder your holdings, meaning you have some bonds coming due every few years. This way if rates rise, as your bonds mature, you can reinvest at higher rates. But in the meantime, you’re getting paid more today.
  • You can ladder with individual holdings or also look into using some high-quality, passively managed bond ETFs. Many bond ETFs are targeted to a certain maturity range, such as short or intermediate term bonds.
  • Remember, the return you want on bonds is the income return from the interest payments. Laddering provides a very simple and effective method to capture those interest payments without requiring you to time interest rate changes.

Dividends. And don’t forget that one of the better long term inflation hedges has been a growing dividend stream from a diversified stock portfolio. Usually, stock dividends grow at a pace faster than inflation over the long term. So any increasing dividends will also help to offset inflation down the road.

  • While dividend payments are not guaranteed, there’s a reasonably high probability that your dividend payments will outpace inflation through your retirement years.

Bottom line. Inflation protection is important, but it’s not the only thing retirees need to be concerned about. Be prepared to deal with inflation down the road, but you should also consider prudent strategies for generating more interest in today’s environment.

As with all financial matters, consult your individual financial advisor prior to making any decisions.

 
Reply to Story

MoneyWatch TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    larry swedroe

    09/22/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Don't Go Overboard With Inflation Protection

    "But the problem with TIPS today is they don?t produce much income for you to live on. So if you load up on TIPS and we don?t get high inflation, or it takes years for inflation to emerge, you may be forced to spend more of your principal to pay the bills."

    The problem with this statement is that if inflation does not emerge you will not be forced to spend more of your principal. In fact, one of the major advantages of TIPS is that they allow you to extend maturities, earning the term premium (assuming curve is positively sloped which it currently is) without taking inflation risk. Currently can earn over 2% real return by purchasing TIPS with maturities of 2025 or longer.

    In fact TIPS look incredibly cheap currently. Here is why. The ten year Treasury is now about 3.5% and the ten year TIPS about 1.7%. So the breakeven rate is 1.8%. Yet the Philly Fed consensus forecast by professional forecasters (a good indicator of the market's estimate of inflation) for long term inflation is 2.5%. Theoretically TIPS should yield less than the difference because they provide insurance against unexpected inflation. And investors, being risk averse, should be willing to pay some risk premium for that protection. Thus, IMO relative to nominal Treasury bonds TIPS are a screaming buy.

    As to equities, they are simply not an inflation hedge. They are far to volatile to serve that purpose. Stocks over the very long term HAVE provided a return above inflation. But that is not because they have inflation, but because they are risky investments and investors have been rewarded with a premium for taking risk. TIPS hedge inflation over the long term -and that makes them the riskless instrument--assuming you hold to maturity.

  •  
    2

    Charles Farrell

    09/22/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Don't Go Overboard With Inflation Protection

    I think you're wrong on both counts Larry. TIPS currently provide minimal cash flow, and if you're retired, cash flow today, this month, next week and next year is critical. Not much cash flow on TIPS. As I say, great long term inflation hedge, but not much help in paying the bills this year. You can't eat theoretical returns.

    And with respect to the stock comment, I am referring to dividends not equity or stock prices. Go back and check the growth of the dividend stream (actual cash dividends paid) on the S&P 500 over the last 10 years and then compare it to the index value, and you'll see what I'm talking about. If retired, you can strip out the dividend payments to fund living expenses.

    The purpose of the post is not that you don't need inflation protection, it's that you shouldn't go overboard with it if you're retired.

  •  
    3

    larry swedroe

    09/22/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Don't Go Overboard With Inflation Protection

    Charles
    We will agree to disagree on both counts. But I will add this: one big mistake people make is to manage portfolios based on "cash flow" instead of a total return approach.

  •  
    4

    Charles Farrell

    09/22/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Don't Go Overboard With Inflation Protection

    That's where we differ, in retirement, we manage for cash flow, and let total return take care of itself. I can calculate cash flow, but can't predict total return. It's not a big mistake, it's really the only way to value an investment, and if the cash flow is good, the valuations eventually follow. Everything else is just a guess. And in the meantime, there's real money available to live on.

  •  
    5

    larry swedroe

    09/23/09 | Report as spam

    RE: Don't Go Overboard With Inflation Protection

    Charley
    You are right, we totally disagree. It makes no difference whether in retirement or not, the only right way to manage a portfolio is total return, not cash flow.


Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement

Charlie Farrell

Charles Farrell, J.D., LL.M. is an investment advisor with Northstar Investment Advisors in Denver, Colorado. He works primarily with individuals and families on the management and funding of their retirement savings, and is a former tax attorney. His research on retirement and investing has been widely published in major media outlets including The Wall Street Journal, Money Magazine, Journal of Financial Planning, and The Investment News.

Charlie Farrell

track your portfolio